Sometimes we don’t even believe ourselves

I went to a talk about victim impact statements in the context of the trial of the rapist and serial molester Larry Nassar.
After the speakers, one of whom is a sociology professor and a lawyer, described what Nassar had done, which was to sexually assault dozens of young women and girls, some of them as young as six years old,
and after the speakers shared what some of the survivors had said in court during their victim impact statements –
that is, after 45 minutes of discussion of how Nassar had assaulted girls and how they had told their parents and the police and other relevant authorities and nobody had believed them,
an older white man asked if anyone has ever done a sociological study of why authorities don’t believe women who report assault.
Sociology professor/lawyer (female): Why weren’t they believed?
Man: Yes! They told the police! They told the authorities!
Sociology professor: Pfft. This is what happens when women report rape.
It is indeed what happens. Women are not believed.
This story is from a 2022 study, “Unfounded Sexual Assault: Women’s Experiences of Not Being Believed by the Police.”
Although some women were told directly by the police that they did not believe them, others indicated that there was a pivotal moment in the process with the police that led them to believe that the police were dismissing their accounts. For some women, this moment occurred when the police stopped writing things down; for others, it was when a particularly offensive or doubtful question was asked, or a comment was made regarding their character. One woman who was questioned about how she knew that she was being touched with a man’s penis disclosed this interaction with police as a pivotal moment where she realized she was not being believed:
NIHI was hurt. It was like why aren’t you listening to me, why aren’t you hearing what I’m telling you. I mean, he was sitting there fondling my breast while my hand was sliding up and down on his whatever. Like I don’t understand why they don’t listen? I don’t understand why you are pouring your heart and soul out to this guy [police], and all you want is help, and he’s like how do you know that’s true? How do you know that happened? And I was like because I was fucking there, that’s how I know it happened.
Unfortunately, this study doesn’t delve much into the why beyond some victims just aren’t the right kind of victims.
But this 2019 PBS story does include speculation about the why.
Soraya Chemaly: I mean, I think part of the issue with MeToo is sort of the flip side, which is men quietly thinking me too. Like, if he did that, I have done that. Does that make me this person?
And, really, it comes down to an interrogation of masculinity and manhood. We see in survey after survey that men are much more likely to doubt women’s testimonies, unless they themselves have been assaulted….
It’s the men — I mean, I believe, in our culture, we have many more boys and men who are assaulted than we are willing to admit to or who can come forward, because, in fact, their shame is very, very deep.
It usually takes a man until he’s in his 50s or 60s to come forward. And so, if a man has experienced assault, he responds to stories of assault the way a typical woman does, which is much more sympathy or empathy or likelihood to find the testimony credible.
And so I think it’s hard for men because, in fact, if all the women around them are saying this is happening, we’re being threatened or harassed, it means they are failing, in fact, to perform a fundamental function of their manhood, which is to protect them.
Why we often don’t believe women who report sexual assault
TLDR: Men don’t think rape happens until it happens to them.
And some men have assaulted or date raped women and now they are being forced to confront their own actions.
Rather than admit that they have done wrong or have been wronged or have prevented a wrong from happening, these men deny that that wrong exists.
They are not rapists themselves. They have not been raped. They have not ignored it when their friends have raped.
Because if rape exists and if women tell the truth, then these men have to confront horrible truths about themselves.
How many of us have had sexual experiences that we would describe as less than ideal? Experiences for which if we used the proper language – rape, assault – we would also have to use the proper language for the man who perpetuated the rape or the assault?
Rapist.
Sexual assaulter.
How many of these men would describe themselves with those words?
Probably about zero, I guess.
I still think about a guy – I hesitate to use the word boyfriend because it makes him sound OK – who I saw a few times.
Let’s call him JD for John Doe, although I would love love love to use his real name, but he is now a highly-respected businessman and politician in Austin who is undoubtedly convinced that he is one of the Good Guys and I am not interested in being sued.
JD was my friends’ boss when we all lived in Austin. I was 23 and he was in his early 30s. We met at happy hour and then at his going-away party when he was leaving Austin for grad school out of state. He had moved out of his Austin place and was on his way to see his sister in Houston before going to school.
He flirted. I was flattered. I thought he was sophisticated and handsome.
He called me the next day from Houston and asked me out.
I said yes.
He returned to Austin. We went out. He drove me back to my apartment.
I said goodbye.
He said he had thought he would stay with me.
I laughed.
He did not.
He was serious.
I was an idiot.
This was the part where I should have said “Dude you have lived in Austin for over ten years. You have plenty of friends you can stay with. Good. Night.”
I did not.
I let him in.
So everything that follows is my fault, right?
He tried to convince me to let him sleep in my bed instead of the couch.
And to have sex.
And after an hour of this, I was so exhausted that I agreed, just to get him to shut the fuck up.
He returned over his break and stayed with me again.
(Again – I *asked* for this, right? I *consented.* So it’s my fault.)
And then I wised up and started to ignore him.
He wrote me a letter telling me he wanted me to move to California with him. (Not asking me to marry him. Just wanting me to quit my job and move to another state with him. Outside of everything else, he expected me to uproot myself and take a ton of risk on his behalf? While he made no commitment at all?)
I ignored him.
He told me not to be afraid of my passion.
I ignored him.
He called and left me a message telling me he was driving to Austin that day and would see me soon.
I not only ignored him, I also Ieft my apartment for the day.
I never saw him again.
I never thought the words rape or assault applied to me.
I was no victim.
I was in complete control of my story and my life.
It has taken me decades to realize that DAMN HE SHOULD HAVE STOPPED ASKING THE FIRST TIME I SAID NO.
These young women knew right away that what was happening was wrong, even when their own parents tried to explain away what the rapist was doing while he was supposed to be treating them for injuries.
They knew it was bad. They knew it was wrong.
I am so proud of these young women for speaking up.
I am so proud that they knew something was wrong and that they persisted.
I am so proud that they had the courage to stand up and point a finger.
Larry Nassar will die in prison.











