I am derivative

If I don’t have a man, who am I?

Do you see that beautiful bird?

It’s a Red-Winged Blackbird.

Yes, really!

No, it’s not black.

No, it doesn’t have red wings.

But guess what it does have?

A mate that is black with red wings.

Photo by Nicki Dick on Pexels.com

The photo I took is of a female Red-Winged Blackbird.

The one above from Pexels is a male Red-Winged Blackbird.


Another example.

What do you see here?

Photo by Skyler Ewing on Pexels.com

Describe this bird using words. What would you name it? A Crested Red-Beaked Fluffball?

That’s a descriptive name, right?

Guess what it’s really called?

It’s a Cardinal.

BUT WAIT YOU SAY IT’S NOT EVEN RED ALL OVER!

Nope.

Because it’s a female Cardinal.

This, my friends, is a male Cardinal. Notice how he is actually – red?

Photo by Tina Nord on Pexels.com

My sweet raised in a different time grandmother always referred to women by their husband’s name: “Mrs Don Schmitz ” instead of “Sally Schmitz.”

She didn’t stop there. She called entire families by the father’s name: “The Jake Jacobson’s sold their farm.” “The John Staab’s had us over for sheepshead.”

She was a product of her time and I guess so were the scientists who named the birds. But – did it ever occur to the bird namers that their names were inaccurate?


How do you look at a male Bluebird and a female Bluebird and decide that the name should be “Bluebird?”

I bet you can’t guess which of these is the male?

Hahahaha. I joke. Of course you can!


When I got married, I changed my surname because I wasn’t philosophically opposed to the idea.

And then I learned more.

And I became extremely philosophically opposed to the idea.

Like – furiously philosophically opposed to the idea.

So I changed back to my maiden name. (With all the disclaimers that this, too, perpetuates The Patriarchy and “maiden” has implications that are just gross, etc, etc.)

I changed because I had grown to hate the practice, because I missed my old name, and because I knew it would anger Mr T’s parents, who by then had become my sworn enemies.

I knew they would see it as a rejection of them and indeed it was.

They continued to call me “Mrs Mr T.”

But my own mother, whom I love and who loves me in return, also continued to address envelopes and refer to me as “Mrs Mr T” and “Texan Mr T.”

She had a really hard time with reverting to addressing me by my maiden (ick ick ick) name.


How do you look straight at something and give it a name that doesn’t describe it?

How do you change the mindset that only men and males matter?


(My mom now refers to me as “Texan” and she has grown to hate the president. I guess I did inherit the ability to change from her.)

If you’re not telling the truth to your friends

Then you are not telling it to yourself

The amazing Helga Stentzel

I found a stack of old letters, including one my friend and former housemate Bliss had written to me after she got married. I had sent her socks – SOCKS! – as a wedding present and she, ever gracious, thanked me for them.

They were handmade socks that I had found in Chile, where I was a Peace Corps volunteer, and were very cool socks, but still – I gave her socks as a wedding present.


But that’s not the story.

Before I joined the Peace Corps, I was dating Brad. He was super funny and smart and interesting and we had been friends for about a year before anything romantic happened. It had been clear to me that entire time that he wanted more than friendship, but I just didn’t feel that spark.

Translation: He was not hot. To me.

But after a bad breakup with Jerky McJerkFace (that is, JMcJF wanted to break up and he broke up by asking out my friend Darcy while I was away for a semester abroad – a semester abroad where I missed him so much that I came back after only a week, which was a big fat waste of plane fare and I destroyed my chance for a semester abroad, something I had always wanted to do I am an idiot) where almost the entire basis for the relationship was JMcJF’s hotness and his amazing kissing ability, I decided perhaps chemistry was not the most important thing.

(Darcy was a new friend and he gave her the impression that he and I had broken up before I left for Amsterdam. We had not. At least, I had not. She spent a year trying to repair our friendship and I finally relented and when we compared notes, we discovered JMcJF had used the same lines on us. He didn’t even bother to get original material. He has since faded into the ether, his career a big failure hahahahaha and Darcy and I have been solid for decades. We don’t talk about him anymore because he is boring.)

I chose friendship.

I decided that friendship was more important than chemistry.


Reader it turns out that friendship is not more important than chemistry.


It turns out that no matter how much you want it to be so, no matter how much you just like a person, kissing someone with whom you have no chemistry is just – boring.

It wasn’t just that it was boring.

It was also that bless his sweet heart he was a very bad kisser. Very bad. Very very bad.

But I never told my friends.

So when I wrote to Bliss – in a note that went with her wedding socks – that I was thinking of breaking up with Brad, she wrote back to say I was nuts. She reminded me how much I liked him. How much I liked his family.

And I remembered, reading her words to me, 30 years later, that I had never admitted to my friends that the sex was so, so bad.

I had focused only on the positive.

I didn’t tell the truth.

I didn’t tell the truth to the friends I knew best – the ones who knew me best – and who would give me the advice I needed to hear.

Because I know if I had breathed one word to her about the s-e-x, Bliss would have said, “What? NO! You cannot stay with someone where you don’t like the sex! It will not get better! It will not!

If I had breathed one word to any of my friends, they would have said the same thing.

Which is why I didn’t breathe a word.

Because I knew but I didn’t want to know.

Once you know – once you admit the truth, you have to do something.


I broke up with him.

By letter.

From South America.

Well I wasn’t going to call him and that was my other communication option.

I’m glad I broke up with him but sorry I ever got romantically involved with him because I lost him as a friend.

I googlestalk him occasionally. I think he’s happy. I hope he is. He’s married to a woman who looks super interesting and accomplished. Looks like they have a nice daughter. He is successful in his chosen profession. It worked out for him and I am glad.


And I sent that letter back to Bliss with notes and an apology for giving her socks as her wedding present.

I got a letter back from her today where she told me that her husband still has the socks and he still wears them.

I didn’t know what I didn’t know

But I never even thought to ask

This image has nothing to do with this post, but I am too lazy to look for images of shame and I love this poem.

Ten years ago, my friend Claudia, who lived in Texas, posted on facebook that she was selling a lot of her workout wear.

She was an exercise instructor – I met her at a Jazzercise class and we became fast friends – and I assumed she was just purging inventory.

I bought some of it, but there was a tiny judgy part of me that thought, “I would just give away my extras to my friends.”


When I was in high school, my friend Ramona never invited me to her house. She would come to my house, though, and we would go to movies together and we were in the CYO together and we sat next to each other on the bus and she was always happy to hang out.

(Although to my eternal shame, I called her one time to go to the movies and she couldn’t and my response was, “But I’ve already asked everyone else!” WHO SAYS THAT TO A DEAR FRIEND WHAT WAS I THINKING?)

(Like – it’s been 45 years and I still remember this and I still cringe in horror that I said something so thoughtless and cruel to someone I loved.)

Anyhow. She never invited me to her house. I don’t think I was ever once in her house.


When Mr T and I first moved to our house in Wisconsin, we noticed a middle-aged guy walking his dogs a lot, even in the middle of the day. The guy had an odd gait – leaning forward, with one stiff leg, hesitating with each step.

“Drunk,” Mr T and I said, rolling our eyes at each other. “Doesn’t have a job and lives in his mother’s basement.”

We called him The Weird Drunk Guy.


Seven years ago, I was in Austin and had lunch with Claudia.

She told me she was preparing to leave her husband, a tech executive who, it turns out, had been having hookups their entire marriage.

What’s worse, they were gay hookups.

It’s not bad that he was gay – it’s bad that he knew he was gay but had married her anyway as a beard. It’s one thing to make a deal with someone to be your beard, but to trick someone into thinking you love her and want to be with her? That’s platinum-level assholery there.

He didn’t share his income. He paid for the house, but anything else she needed – clothes, car, doctor, she had to pay for. From her earnings as an exercise instructor.

He had also taken out credit card applications in her name and run the cards to the limit on his auto-racing hobby.

She had no money.


When we were 32, Ramona’s mother took her own life.

Ramona is the one who found her.

That’s when Ramona told me that her parents were alcoholics and she was expected to clean the house every day after school and make supper.

She had never breathed a word of this when we were in high school and I never thought to ask.


A few years after we moved into our house, I was talking to one of my neighbors with dogs. I mentioned The Weird Drunk Guy and the neighbor said, “Oh you mean Doug? He has MS. He lives on disability. He walks as much as possible to slow the progression of his disease.”

When my neighbor told me what was really going on with Doug, I felt a flush rise in my face and I wanted to sink into the ground with shame.


I am a judgey, judgey person. I criticize people in my head all the time. I roll my eyes at things I think are dumb.

But damn almost every time I do that, I get more information and discover IATA.

I’m trying to be better. I am.

(Although I still totally judge trump voters.)

(I mean.)

(Although I am happy to forgive if they see the error of their ways and join The Revolution.)

When the rapist is the hero

And the gay grandchild is the villain

My friend Lisa – she of the fascinating blog that mixes fashion and politics and philosophy – and I have been trying to figure out how Stephen Miller makes himself the hero of his own story.

What does he tell himself at night when he’s waiting to fall asleep and he’s going over his day in his mind? “I have rid the country of Dangerous People, including the Paleta Guy in California! American citizens can sleep better tonight!”

How does he twist the truth – the evil – of his actions to justify them?

How does he make evil beautiful?


The professor for one of my Shakespeare classes had us cast the plays with Hollywood actors. When we were casting “Othello,” we wanted to put someone like Danny DeVito, who had been playing villains, in the role of Iago.

My professor said no, it needed to be someone like Robert Redford.

“Evil is beautiful,” he said. “If it were ugly, it would be harder for it to seduce you.”

(A question I wish we had discussed as well is, “How did Iago make himself the hero in this story? Did he really believe Desdemona was cheating on Othello?”)


A friend said, “The devil comes to you as everything you ever thought you wanted.”

Evil doesn’t look like evil.

If evil looked like evil, most of us would reject it.


A friend’s parents discowned her.

Her son is gay. He does drag.

The son had not come out to his grandparents.

My friend – who knew what her parents are like – tried to keep the information about her son off facebook, but other people tagged her in some posts about the son’s drag show and her parents saw the posts.

They sent her a facebook message telling her that they would, in the future, be choosing not to put themselves in the same space as my friend and her son.


What story do you tell yourself to make yourself the hero for disowning your child and your grandchild?

What story do you tell yourself to make disowning your child and your grandchild the beautiful thing, not the evil thing?

In what world is your gay, drag-star grandchild so evil that you must reject him?

Let me rephrase that: In what world is your gay, drag-star grandchild more evil than a convicted rapist, felon, adulterous man who’s not even kin?

Because the added context that probably helps explain this story is that the parents are trumpers. (My friend is not.) That’s not to say that only trumpers reject gay grandchildren, but if you make a Venn diagram of “People who reject gay grandchildren who perform in drag” and “trumpers,” I bet you will have almost a perfect circle.


We live in a world where gay grandchildren are evil but masked men grabbing people off the streets and sending them to concentration camps is not evil.

Where cutting medical care for poor people is not evil.

Where forcing the family watch their pregnant, brain-dead daughter’s body exist on artificial life support until physicians finally have to cut the premature baby out of the the daughter’s decomposing body is not evil.

Where trying to rob people of their citizenship is not evil.

Where cutting funding for cancer research is not evil.

Where the heroes are the people who turn their backs on their children and grandchildren while embracing a dictator.

I have no answers except that we need to start calling evil by its name.